WINNERS
Weeds: Mary-Louise Parker will go to Heaven.
Prison Break: Triumphant reinvention of the serial genre.
Supernatural: Hot guys, cold thrills, great writing.

LOSERS
Reunion (Great concept; unfortunately, script ideas were handed over to 12-year-old children to write)

TOO CLOSE TO CALL
Rome

NOT YET JUDGED (Not Premiered or on TiVo)
Bones
Kitchen Confidential
How I Met Your Mother
Head Cases